Amy Adams stars as an agoraphobic woman confined to her large New York home. While observing the new neighbors across the street, she sees something disturbing…or does she? Her mental condition compromises her credibility, but there are more issues. Even with the twists, the writing isn’t always effective (penned by Tracy Letts, who also plays a role). While Adams is trying her darndest to draw us into her world, her performance is a bit grating. She has an A-level cast supporting her, including Gary Oldman and Julianne Moore. Director Joe Wright brings his directorial flair with some moments of sly Hitchcock references. There are a few expected twists, but almost no tension to accompany the paranoia. Even though it’s mildly intriguing and the final encounter does have some bite, the whole thing feels a bit off and uneven in tone and execution. 
(3 / 5)
