In the last month THREE shows have featured iconic Black singers:
Genius: Aretha, is NOT the authorized version of the singer’s life (that will be released as a movie starring Jennifer Hudson)
Mahalia is a biopic from Lifetime
Tina is a documentary
Genius: Aretha Nat Geo’s Genius series examines the life of Aretha Franklin during her formative and peak years. There are numerous (actually too many) flashbacks to her early days, singing gospel on the road with her father (played by Courtney B. Vance with charisma and depth). The story manages to dredge up several unpleasant events, including cursory attention to her several husbands and a bit of time with her sons. What makes the series so successful is Cynthia Ervio, who beautifully channels Franklin when she sings…and there are lots of songs (none of the biggest hits, which I imagine are being saved for the aforementioned movie). While a lot of landmarks are covered, the career momentum gets in the way of creating an emotional story, even with the generous visits to her past. 
(3.5 / 5)
Tina PBS recently aired Tina Turner’s incredible final concert movie and this documentary serves as an appropriate partner. Turner authorized this and she appears from her home in Switzerland. Naturally, there’s a plethora of performance footage dating back to her days with Ike. What’s surprising is some of the major points that get little or no coverage: her seminal tour with the Rolling Stones, her offspring and her major illnesses. Since Turner was obviously involved, many of the “warts and all” are avoided. Even so, there’s so much input and so much to enjoy that it’s easy to just bask in her glorious presence. 
(4 / 5)
Mahalia Lifetime produced this series about legendary gospel singer Mahalia Jackson. As a result, don’t expect any depth in the dialogue or issues. Danielle Brooks does a commendable job in recreating the woman, especially with her powerful voice. It’s unfortunate that the writing never moves beyond the surface and repeats some subjects too often. For those who know little about Jackson, this will serve as a dutiful biopic. 
(2.5 / 5)